Petraeus wrote: Freedom of navigation cannot mean “
temporary grants from Tehran to favored nations,”
nor
“routes Iran can close whenever it chooses,”
nor
“a temporary pause in attacks conditioned on concessions.”
He establishes a practical benchmark:
“The test is whether ships move routinely, insurers cover voyages, and energy cargoes reach world markets reliably.”
What Lies Behind the Text:
At first glance, this argument appears reasonable. At its core, however, it seeks to permanently strip Iran of its leverage over the Strait of Hormuz rather than negotiate over it.
The benchmark Petraeus sets — the regular movement of ships and the availability of insurance coverage — can only be achieved through sustained American military pressure, which in turn serves the stability of the investment environment he represents.
Third: The Nuclear File
🖋 Petraeus wrote: Before inspectors lost access in June 2025, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) estimated that Iran possessed 440.9 kilograms (972 pounds) of uranium enriched to 60% — classified as
“highly enriched uranium”
that could be used in a crude nuclear device without further enrichment.
Since then, “
the agency has lost track of the stockpile’s loca
tion and condition.”
He therefore demanded that any agreement include:
• A complete declaration and renewed inspections, followed by the verified removal and export of the material — or its dilution through downblending.
• A cap on enrichment at civilian levels.
• Restrictions on uranium stockpiles and advanced centrifuges.
• Continuous monitoring and rapid access to suspected nuclear sites.
The objective, he argues, is not
“merely to dispose of yesterday’s material, but to prevent Iran from quickly recreating the same nuclear threat tomorrow.”
What Lies Behind the Text:
These are sweeping, irreversible demands that would effectively strip Iran’s nuclear program of its substance.
On the surface, they are presented as measures of “nonproliferation.” In reality, however, they would place Iran in a position where it could no longer retain any nuclear bargaining leverage, while Israel — Washington’s strategic ally — remains exempt from comparable restrictions.

