Washington

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio stated that

“Shia clerics in Iran”

are the common denominator behind every major problem in the Middle East, linking them to the support provided to Hezbollah, resistance factions in Iraq, and Ansar Allah in Yemen.

However, this rhetoric conflates Iran as a political state with Shiism as a religious and intellectual tradition that transcends national borders.

The religious thought embodied in the Islamic Republic is not an exclusively Iranian creation. Rather, it is the cumulative intellectual heritage of scholars from across the Islamic world — including non-Shia scholars — making it far deeper and broader than something that can be confined to a single geographical territory.

What fundamentally concerns the United States is an intellectual phenomenon that has manifested itself in Iran, but whose roots and influence extend far beyond Iranian borders.

Nevertheless, official American rhetoric tends to reduce every movement opposing Western hegemony to nothing more than an “Iranian proxy.”

By associating all Shia thought with the Islamic Republic, Rubio attempts to cast doubt on the independence of religious scholars and local actors, while disregarding the historical roots, demands, and autonomous decision-making of these movements.

In this context, the wording used by Pentagon spokesperson John Kirby in March 2021 is particularly significant. Kirby referred to

“Shia-backed militias”

rather than

“Iran-backed militias.”

This distinction reflects an awareness that, from Washington’s perspective, the challenge is not limited to one particular state but extends to a broader ideological and religious framework that transcends geographical boundaries.