Engineering Chaos: How Are the Defeated Brought Back into the Political Arena?

The issue here goes beyond al-Alwani’s killing as a means of distracting the Axis of Resistance and draining its attention. His release from prison was, and continues to be, a tool serving the same purpose. However, the objective extends far beyond temporary distraction.

In countries such as Iraq and Lebanon, where government decision-making often remains subject to Western influence, periodic elections continue to reshuffle the political landscape. This forces those powers to seek ways of sidelining the anti-Western political environment—not through decisive military action, but by reintroducing those who lost their war against the state, its institutions, and the social fabric.

Those who were defeated on the battlefield are now being brought back into the arena through figures such as al-Alwani, al-Kaakoura, and Ahmad al-Assir—not to become “partners in reconciliation,” but to reorganize themselves and play their designated role in destabilizing the domestic political landscape.

Those who failed to impose their project through armed force are being reintroduced through politics, ensuring that the anti-Western camp remains preoccupied with internal struggles rather than focusing on confronting the external enemy.

Thus, amnesty is transformed from a “settlement” into a mechanism for reproducing instruments of political pressure. The price is paid through the erosion of state authority, the morale of its security forces, and respect for the blood that has been shed.

The Shocking Message to Security Forces and the Public

What message do such laws send to the general public, and particularly to members of the security forces?

The message is clear: Your blood means nothing when weighed against major political deals—whether among politicians themselves or between them and countries that dominate the sovereign decision-making of Iraq and Lebanon, such as the United States and Saudi Arabia.

And the result?

There is no reason to make sacrifices for a state that does not respect itself or its people, and for which law and sovereignty mean nothing. A state that, under foreign pressure, can amend its laws and release some of the most notorious terrorist figures on record, allowing them to reorganize themselves once again.

When an ordinary security officer sees a case of this magnitude closed through an “amnesty,” “blood money,” or a “political deal,” the natural question becomes:

Why should I sacrifice my life? And for whom?

A Formidable Enemy, Not Merely an Insignificant Figure

This brings us to the circumstances surrounding his killing.

Was al-Alwani someone without influence, or was he a genuine enemy? Certainly, he was not an insignificant figure.

Had he been unimportant, he would have remained in prison for the rest of his life. The judiciary and government would not have gone to such lengths to justify his release, blood money would not have been paid, and the entire affair would not have generated such controversy.

His eleven years in prison, followed by his release, are all indications that he was not merely a “former enemy,” but an actor whose influence still had to be taken into account.

Beyond the Bullet: The Collapse of the Killers’ Illusion of Safety

Who killed him?

Was it elements affiliated with the Axis of Resistance? Was it an internal settling of scores within the opposing camp? Or was it an individual crime exploited to inflame sectarian tensions?

We raise these possibilities, but they matter less to us than what lies beyond the surrounding uproar.

Setting aside accusations from all sides, the political exploitation of his killing, and renewed sectarian rhetoric, one clear message emerges:

Figures associated with terrorist movements whose hands are stained with the blood of hundreds upon hundreds of innocent people, and who contributed to tearing apart the social fabric, must not feel safe wherever they may be.